City of Houston from Rice: Update

[Second Update: Believe it or not, this mystery got picked up by the Houston Chronicle.]

So my commenters and I have pretty well concluded that this couldn’t have been taken from the top of the Administration Building circa 1915:

Not only is the layout of streets unfamiliar but as you can see in this aerial of the area that  in 1917 there wasn’t anything near the campus at all:

It’s hard to see what direction you could point a camera from Rice to get that view of an urban scene at that date.

It’s theoretically possible that it was taken later but that doesn’t solve the problem of not recognizing the street grid and furthermore I think it really looks 1915ish.

That leaves the question of how to account for the mistake and here I have a theory. I had noticed long ago that before he gave his scrapbook to the archives Elmer Shutts went through it and added new labels to old photographs. Here’s a clear example:

You can easily see that the label at the top is newer than the one on the bottom, which looks to have been contemporaneous with the picture.  If you go back and look at the label on the image of the city it’s pretty clear that it was added later too. This makes me suspect that the older Shutts just didn’t look all that closely or didn’t remember accurately where he’d taken that photo.

I’m satisfied with that although I’d still like to know what that picture is showing us.

Bonus:

 

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to City of Houston from Rice: Update

  1. Wolfgang says:

    I am almost positive there are hills in that photo. The non-uniform darker background shades on the sides the photo cannot be attributed to vignetting; I believe this might not even be Houston at all.

  2. marmer01 says:

    I don’t think San Angelo was that big in 1915, was it? I’m thinking Austin or El Paso assuming hills.

  3. Galloway Hudson '60 says:

    So, sadly, UT beats Rice – yet again..

  4. Martha Aguilar '76 says:

    Here’s a link to an image of Houston A Modern City from the Library of Congress. You can see the Rice Hotel and I think the view from there would be more commercial than residential.
    https://www.loc.gov/resource/g4034h.pm009160/

    Here’s a photo of the Old Main building on the UT campus from 1920. It does look like the building in middle of Elmer Shutts’ photo. You can see the esplanade in front of Old Main in both photos as well as a smokestack to the right of Old Main.

    He, or someone, may have been doing a batch labeling of his photos and assumed it was from Rice.

    Look at all the smokestacks along the bayou in the Houston image. Do you know what industries were located there at the time?

  5. Rex Martin says:

    The Austin picture was most definitely taken from south of UT campus, looking north. Photographer was standing somewhere high up in the Capitol Building. Cool!

  6. Isn’t it great that you have a cadre of obsessive research minions?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s